Authorities to take resolution inside two days on class 12 board exams: AG tells SC

New Delhi: The federal government will take a last resolution inside the subsequent two days on whether or not to conduct class 12 board exams amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, the Supreme Courtroom was knowledgeable on Monday

Lawyer Normal Okay Okay Venugopal informed this to a bench of Justices A M Khanwilkar and Dinesh Maheshwari which mentioned if the Centre decides to depart from the final yr’s coverage, whereby the remaining board exams have been cancelled because of the pandemic, then it should give “tangible causes” for it.


“No problem. You’re taking the choice. You’re entitled to it. If you’re departing from the coverage of final yr, then you could give tangible causes for it,” the bench informed Venugopal.

Observing that the final yr’s resolution was taken after deliberations, the apex court docket mentioned, “If you’re departing from that coverage, please give us good causes in order that we are able to look at it.”

The bench was listening to a plea in search of instructions to cancel the category 12 exams of the Central Board of Secondary Training (CBSE) and Council for the Indian Faculty Certificates Examination (CISCE) amid the pandemic state of affairs.


The apex court docket on June 26, 2020 had permitted the schemes of the CBSE and CISCE for cancellations of remaining board examinations scheduled from July 1 to 15 final yr because of the COVID-19 pandemic and likewise permitted their formulation for evaluation of examinees.

Through the listening to performed by way of video-conferencing on Monday, the Lawyer Normal informed the bench, “The federal government will take a last resolution inside the subsequent two days. We hope that your lordships will give us time until Thursday (June 3) in order that we are able to come again with the ultimate resolution”.


Venugopal mentioned that final yr, board exams for some papers have been over earlier than the COVID-19 induced nationwide lockdown was imposed in March 2020.

“We do not wish to go into the nitty-gritty at this stage. You’re taking the choice. Hope has been expressed by the petitioner that coverage adopted final yr may be adopted this yr too. If you’re departing from that, you could have tangible causes for it,” the bench noticed.

To this, Venugopal mentioned, “We’ll maintain this in thoughts what you (bench) have mentioned.”

The bench mentioned, “We now have no issue. You’re taking the choice on what ought to be acceptable given the state of affairs we’re in.”


Through the listening to, petitioner Mamta Sharma raised the problem of issue which college students, who want to research overseas after class 12, may face in case the outcomes are delayed.

“Allow them to take the choice. Relying on that, we’ll see. We’ll think about this on Thursday when the in-principle resolution is positioned earlier than us,” the bench mentioned.

“Record on Thursday (June 3) as requested by the lawyer basic because the competent authority is inspecting all of the facets of the matter and is more likely to take in-principle resolution which will likely be positioned earlier than the court docket,” the bench mentioned.


On Could 28, the apex court docket had mentioned it will hear on Could 31 the petition which has additionally sought instructions to plan an “goal methodology” to declare the results of class 12 inside a selected timeframe.

The highest court docket had permitted the petitioner to serve advance copy of the plea on the standing counsel for the respondents — central company, CBSE, ICSE — and likewise on the workplace of the Lawyer Normal.

The petition has arrayed the Centre, the CBSE and the CISCE as respondents within the matter.

The CBSE had on April 14 introduced cancellation of sophistication 10 exams and postponement of sophistication 12 exams in view of the surge in coronavirus circumstances.


The Ministry of Training had not too long ago sought detailed recommendations from the states and Union Territories until Could 25 on the proposals mentioned in a high-level assembly held on the problem.

The CBSE had proposed conducting the exams between July 15-August 26 and the outcome to be declared in September.

The board had additionally proposed two choices: conducting common exams for 19 main topics at notified centres or conducting shorter period exams at respective colleges the place college students are enrolled.

The plea filed within the apex court docket has contended that because of the unprecedented well being emergency and surge in COVID-19 circumstances within the nation, it isn’t doable to conduct the examination and any additional delay would trigger irreparable loss to the way forward for college students.


“In view of the unprecedented well being emergency and rising variety of COVID-19 circumstances within the nation, the conduct of examination (both offline/on-line/blended) in upcoming weeks is just not doable and delay in examination will trigger irreparable loss to the scholars as time is the essence in taking admission in increased training programs in overseas universities,” the plea mentioned.

It has additionally sought setting apart of the notifications, issued final months by the CBSE and the CISCE, solely in respect of the clauses coping with postponement of sophistication 12 examinations.


The petition mentioned it’s the utmost responsibility of the state to handle the well being and security of scholars and on the similar time, to not hamper their increased training and profession prospects.

It mentioned the COVID-19 state of affairs is extra extreme compared to final yr and the respondents ought to undertake the identical standards of assessing the grading/marks of sophistication 12 college students as achieved final yr.

It mentioned that the apex court docket might train its plenary energy below Article 142 of the Structure to direct the respondents to implement the identical methodology as being adopted for sophistication 10 to declare the outcome and cancel the category 12 examination.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *